diablo1

Title pretty much says it all... I need to get some all seasons on the S5, and I've narrowed it down to these two. The only other choice from TireRack is the Goodyear F1, but that gets significantly lower marks across the board. I was going to go with the Michelins, but then I noticed that the Yokos are the same price and have the same or better ratings for pretty much every category. Would love to hear any feedback. I had Continental ContiExtremeContact a/s tires on my IS350, but they don't make them in the right size for the S5 (255/35/19). I live in NYC and go for occasional trips to NH/VT in the winter, but not enough to justify dedicated winter rims/tires, I don't think. Thank for your help!